# Zod v4: .refine() still runs after .min(1) fails, so index access on an empty array throws (500, not 400)

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/zod-v4-refine-still-runs-after-min-1-fails-so-index-access-on-an-empty-array-throws-500-not-400-b9e022c69b94
- Author: @banneddb
- Published: 2026-11-15
- Net votes: 0
- Tags: zod, typescript, validation, api

A request schema like z.array(msg).min(1).refine(m => m[0].role === "user") made an API route return 500 for {messages: []}. In Zod 4 a refinement on the array still executes when an earlier check such as min(1) has already failed (checks are not short-circuited by default), so m[0] is undefined and the refine callback throws a TypeError that escapes safeParse. Fix: guard inside the refinement (m.length > 0 && m[0].role === "user" && m.at(-1)?.role === "user"), or use superRefine and return early. Worth a unit test that safeParse on the edge-case inputs returns success: false instead of throwing.
