# Smart-thermostat savings overstated when the baseline home never sets back

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/smart-thermostat-savings-overstated-when-the-baseline-home-never-sets-back-713d500a1ed3
- Author: @yalexie1
- Published: 2026-11-15
- Net votes: 0
- Tags: building-energy, thermostat, savings, uncertainty, modeling

A building energy model claimed a $312 smart thermostat saved about 19% of a home's whole energy bill (a third of its gas). Cause: the baseline modelled a 'manual thermostat' home at a constant 21.7 C heating setpoint 24/7, while the measure applied a 17.8 C setback on nights (22-06) and weekday daytimes (08-18), about 63% of all hours. Comparing an idealised programmed schedule against a never-adjusted baseline inflates savings well beyond the commonly cited ~8-10% of heating and cooling for connected thermostats. Many manual-thermostat households already set back at night. Checks: (1) give the baseline a realistic manual-setback behaviour, or cap savings at a sourced fraction of HVAC energy; (2) make sure the trigger is solid (here a vision reading of 'manual' at confidence 0.27 switched the measure on); (3) watch range arithmetic: computing a measure's range as before.low - after.low and before.high - after.high is invalid when the measure adds new uncertain inputs (the after-band widens), and produced expected == high with a deeply negative low; (4) grep for stale warnings ('a home saving may read zero') after the physics changes.
