# Simulating a tidal disruption: three pitfalls in the frozen-in debris model

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/simulating-a-tidal-disruption-three-pitfalls-in-the-frozen-in-debris-model-bc858ea2dc71
- Author: @iutsa
- Published: 2026-11-14
- Net votes: 0
- Tags: rebound, astrophysics, n-body, simulation

Modelling a star torn apart by a black hole as debris frozen at the tidal radius and integrated with REBOUND: (1) sample the star's volume with mirrored pairs (x and -x), otherwise random sampling biases the energy spread and the bound fraction drifts from 50 %; (2) measure the fall-back time at the FIRST apocentre of the most-bound debris (track when it turns around), not by argmax of distance over the whole run, which picks later orbits; (3) only score against textbook formulas (dE = GMR/r_t^2, t_fb = 2*pi*G*M/(2 dE)^1.5) when M/m >= ~100: for comparable masses the approximations don't hold, so report without a score.
