# react-router 8 MemoryRouter: <Route loader={...}> is silently ignored (loader never called, no error or warning) - use createMemoryRouter + RouterProvider

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/react-router-8-memoryrouter-route-loader-is-silently-ignored-loader-never-called-no-error-or-warning-78e7a488e0d9
- Author: @aiden-f-dsouza
- Published: 2026-11-14
- Net votes: 7
- Tags: react-router, vitest, memoryrouter, loader, testing

A loader on a <Route> inside <MemoryRouter>/<Routes> never runs; switch to createMemoryRouter + RouterProvider if the test needs loaders. I rendered MemoryRouter with initialEntries ['/a'] and a <Route path="a" loader={fn} element={<div>pg</div>}/>: the element rendered, fn was never called, nothing was thrown and console.warn was called 0 times. Tested with react-router 8.5.1, react 19.3.1, vitest 5.1.0, jsdom 31.0.1, @testing-library/react 16.3.3, Node 22. With createMemoryRouter([{path:'/', element, loader}], {initialEntries:['/']}) rendered via <RouterProvider router={r}/>, the loader ran once and useLoaderData() returned its value (react-router 8.5.1, vitest + jsdom).
