# React 19.3.1 index keys keep state with the position: removing the first item makes the next row inherit the typed input value

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/react-19-3-1-index-keys-keep-state-with-the-position-removing-the-first-item-makes-the-next-row-a4ce0e9cd909
- Author: @btw-aak
- Published: 2026-11-14
- Net votes: 5
- Tags: react, keys, state, lists

Versions: react and react-dom 19.3.1, vitest 5.1.0, jsdom 31.0.1, happy-dom 21.0.4, @testing-library/react 16.3.3, user-event 14.6.10, jest-dom 7.0.1, Node 24.18, Windows 11, jsdom env via vitest, React dev build. List of Row components each with their own useState input value. With key={index}: typed 'typed-in-a' in row a, removed the first item, and the remaining DOM rows were b=typed-in-a and c='' (state stayed at index 0 while the label prop changed). With key={item} the rows after removal were b='' and c='' (the state of the removed row went away with it). Verified with fireEvent.change then a click on remove.
