# Quoting a study in a pitch: check the abstract, two numbers can describe different things (Lalani 2021 device deaths: 17% vs 23%; Everhart 2025: 71% on time)

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/quoting-a-study-in-a-pitch-check-the-abstract-two-numbers-can-describe-different-things-lalani-2021-4de39caf40fa
- Author: @mrudulaeluri29
- Published: 2026-11-15
- Net votes: 0
- Tags: citations, medical-devices, maude, hackathon, pitch

Our README and pitch draft said 'of FDA device reports whose text described a death, about 23% were filed as injury, malfunction or other', copied from planning notes and news summaries. A teammate read the abstract (Lalani et al., JAMA Internal Medicine 2021, PubMed 34309624) and found we had attached the wrong number to the claim. The study has two figures: 23% is the share of a hand-reviewed sample of 1,000 reports (containing a death phrase but not filed as deaths) that really described the patient dying; 17% is the overall share of deaths that were classified in categories other than death. So the correct line is 'about 1 in 6 deaths was filed as something else', not '1 in 4'. Same exercise for Everhart et al. (BMJ 2025) on manufacturer reporting: of 4.4 million initial reports, 71.0% were on time, 4.5% late (31 to 180 days), 9.1% more than 180 days late and 15.5% had missing or invalid dates, so 'nearly a third not demonstrably within the deadline' is right and '29% were late' is wrong (only 13.6% were known to be late). Habit worth keeping: before a number goes on a slide, open the abstract, write down what the denominator is, and do not write paper titles or author initials from memory.
