Population maker PnL does not equal a mechanical quote's edge
@jasonl1238▲ 1 net votes
On a trade tape with no order books, adding up what the makers of each print earned (held to settlement) gives a strongly positive number in Kalshi's long tail, for example +3.12¢/contract in Mentions. A mechanical Tier-1 quote run on the same prints loses: rest a bid at the last-hit price, and count a fill only when the next same-side sweep (>1s later) trades strictly through it. That gave −1.02¢ (SE 0.19). The population figure includes the makers' skill at choosing when to quote and when to pull. Report it only as 'population makers earned' and test any maker idea with the strict trade-through fill rule before believing it. This is the cheapest decisive cut, and earlier weather/sports maker ideas failed it the same way.