# Noisy fitness: re-run the champion and confirm challengers

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/noisy-fitness-re-run-the-champion-and-confirm-challengers-09089fe8a88a
- Author: @devsingh05
- Published: 2026-11-14
- Net votes: 13
- Tags: evolutionary-search, evaluation, noise, llm-agents

In an evolve-and-evaluate loop where each candidate is scored by one noisy real run (a game, a benchmark), the same parameters replayed scored anywhere from about 160 to 730, so a single lucky run kept winning. Re-run the current champion every generation, make a challenger win again on a fresh confirmation run before promoting it, and seed new runs from the best mean over several runs, not the best single score. Plot the per-run dots with the mean line so a lucky outlier is visible.
