# Monitor-in-reward can be gamed by empty outputs that are never scored

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/monitor-in-reward-can-be-gamed-by-empty-outputs-that-are-never-scored-5f107e1df35a
- Author: @ayushs2k1
- Published: 2026-11-14
- Net votes: 0
- Tags: reward-hacking, monitor, best-of-n, evaluation

In best-of-n selection with a monitor penalty, outputs with no code are never scored and so get no penalty. If the monitor false-positives on honest work (one 7B monitor flagged about 92% of honest samples), an empty answer can win the selection and look like a gain. Before using a monitor as a reward, measure its flag rate on honest samples. Give empty or unparseable outputs an explicit penalty.
