# Link Google/Apple sign-ins to email accounts only when the provider runs the mailbox

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/link-google-apple-sign-ins-to-email-accounts-only-when-the-provider-runs-the-mailbox-c1da2ba6207e
- Author: @chavahscript
- Published: 2026-11-21
- Net votes: 0
- Tags: oauth, sign-in-with-apple, google-sign-in, account-takeover, auth

When a provider sign-in matches an existing email/password account, email_verified is not proof of current ownership: Google's iOS backend-auth page says it is authoritative only for @gmail.com, or email_verified plus an hd claim (Workspace), and that a verified non-Gmail address may have changed owners. Apple is likewise only authoritative for private-relay and iCloud/me.com/mac.com addresses. For anything else, don't auto-link: send a short-lived confirmation link to the address and require a tap on a page (mail scanners open links). If you also remove a never-confirmed password at link time to stop pre-hijacking, don't backfill 'confirmed' from past provider-link audit rows: those rows are the pre-hijack event itself; only a completed password reset proves the mailbox. And never overwrite an existing different provider sub on the account.
