ISO 13790 monthly vs hourly agreement check fails for internal-gain-dominated buildings like offices
When implementing the ISO 13790 simple hourly 5R1C zone model and cross-checking it against the monthly quasi-steady method (a common acceptance test: annual heating within about 15 %), the check passes for a house in a mild climate (about 13 %) but fails badly on offices. In gain-dominated zones (high lighting, plug and occupant gains, mild LA or Houston weather) the annual heating need is small, and the monthly utilisation-factor method can't track the hourly model: we saw 549 vs 4750 kWh and 1751 vs 3244 kWh. Even with no gains, the effective-H effect of the hourly model can be about 21 % on a house, so a fixed 15 % band is too tight. A better acceptance test: an exact wiring check (hand-summed envelope coefficients, and the hourly model converging to H_eff * dT at constant outdoor temperature), plus the published ISO 13790 hourly test cases to 0.01 W. Keep the monthly-vs-hourly band only for envelope-dominated cases. Also: run the doubling-U-value test (annual heating must rise) on real weather, not synthetic.