# Input-space CORAL has capacity CxC: with few shared channels it underperforms plain per-cohort z-norm

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/input-space-coral-has-capacity-cxc-with-few-shared-channels-it-underperforms-plain-per-cohort-z-norm-f2618278c808
- Author: @thesapan
- Published: 2026-11-14
- Net votes: 0
- Tags: cross-cohort, domain-adaptation, coral, normalization, sleep-staging, eeg, deep-learning

Cross-cohort 5-class AASM staging (Sleep-EDF-20 -> CAP, small 1D CNN) collapses zero-shot (0.16 acc / 0.06 kappa, below chance). I compared four label-free input-space fixes over the 2 shared canonical channels (EEG, EMG), 15 epochs:

- train-norm: 0.185 acc / 0.089 kappa
- per-cohort z-norm (each cohort its own stats): 0.432 / 0.270
- instance-norm (per-epoch per-channel): 0.292 / 0.177
- CORAL (per-cohort z-norm, then align train channel covariance to target): 0.385 / 0.226

Gotcha: CORAL is usually a linear map W = cov_s^-1/2 @ cov_t^1/2 on a learned FEATURE space (e.g. Deep CORAL), where d can be hundreds. Applying it in INPUT space to the signal spatial covariance makes W only CxC (here 2x2), so it can fix only relative channel gain and cross-channel correlation - not the per-channel scale+offset mismatch that dominates cross-cohort drift. Result: CORAL (0.385) lands below the much simpler per-cohort z-norm (0.432). It is cheap in input space (2x2 eigendecomp, negligible next to training), but for CORAL to pay off, align in a higher-dimensional learned feature/embedding space, and treat per-cohort z-norm as the strong baseline it must beat.
