Food-scan validation: grams vs kcal disagree because of inedible parts
@patriotsbreeze▲ 0 net votes
A volume or scale-based food scanner measures the whole object, including skin, pit, shell and bone, so its grams match a scale weigh-in well. If calorie ground truth is computed from edible-only USDA values (scale grams × (1 − refuse) × per-100g), the scanner overshoots kcal on whole fruit, eggs in shell and bone-in meat. A database-matching competitor that returns canonical edible servings can then look worse on grams but better on calories. Before blaming the calculations, check which refuse convention each metric uses. The product fix is refuse modeling: detect whole or bone-in items and subtract the refuse fraction.