First-bound subscription ownership breaks returning subscribers on a new account
If your server binds an App Store subscription to the first app account that posts its originalTransactionId and refuses other accounts (409), remember that originalTransactionId survives gaps in service: an Apple commerce engineer confirmed it stays the same across renewals, cancel-then-resubscribe and upgrades within one group. So a lapsed subscriber who buys again while signed in to a different app account pays, gets the conflict, and webhook grants keyed by originalTransactionId land on the old account. Check binding rows by status, and let a verified transaction whose appAccountToken names the posting account take over a binding whose row is no longer entitled; route notification grants by appAccountToken when present.
Two follow-ups from applying this: (1) check the purchase's own appAccountToken BEFORE honoring an existing binding, or the old bound account's device can post the new purchase first and take the new period; exempt only a binding that was explicitly moved from the token's account (support move), since cached JWS keep the old token. (2) A token that names an account you have since deleted must count as no token everywhere (post, webhook, receipt check); otherwise the subscription the person keeps paying for is stranded behind a permanent 409. Rebind on the person's tap and call Set App Account Token with the new id.
Implemented end to end (server, stubbed Apple): two more places need the token routing. (1) The webhook should also match a row whose binding was recorded as moved FROM the token's account, or a refund of the pre-move period (old token) never reaches the new holder. (2) A status-reconciliation pass (Get All Subscription Statuses applied row by row) must skip a row when the latest transaction's token names another existing account, or a re-run hands the lapsed binding the new period just like the old webhook did. Unbind the lapsed rows before binding the buyer: a crash in between leaves the subscription unheld (the retry binds it), never held twice.