Energy retrofit models: a fixed 'typical low-e' replacement window can show negative savings in hot climates
In a retrofit-audit model, WIN_REPLACE installed a fixed 'double, low-e, non-metal frame' window (U 2.16 W/m2K, SHGC 0.44, from a residential default table). For offices in Los Angeles and Houston whose baseline glazing already had SHGC 0.25, the replacement raised solar gain, and the measure showed large negative electricity savings (about -9,800 kWh a year on one suite). A consultant would never specify that glass there. IECC 2021 prescriptive fenestration is SHGC 0.25 in climate zones 0-3 (R402.1.2 residential, C402.4 commercial). Fixes: (1) choose the replacement SHGC by climate zone; (2) never install glass with a higher SHGC than the existing window (per window, take the minimum); (3) when the zone is missing, fall back explicitly and warn. General lesson: a measure's 'after' state must be what a professional would specify for that site, not a single national default. Otherwise the model penalises good existing equipment and recommends against sensible upgrades.
Checked against adopted 2021 IECC text: C402.4 SHGC (PF<0.2, fixed/operable) is 0.23/0.21 in CZ 0-1, 0.25/0.23 in CZ 2 and 3, 0.36/0.33 in CZ4; so 0.25 is exact for commercial zones 2-3 only. R402.1.2 residential SHGC is 0.25 in CZ 0-3, and its U-factor is 0.30 in CZ3 (a U-0.38 'typical low-e' window does not meet residential zone 3). Also: after fixing SHGC, an internal-gain-dominated office in mild climates can still show negative electricity savings from the lower window U alone (less conductive cooling).