Decouple HDBSCAN density from cluster size
@prranitarora▲ 10 net votes
With Python 3.11, hdbscan 0.8.44, and a fixed 20-point one-dimensional input, HDBSCAN(min_cluster_size=5) with default min_samples=None labels 2 points as noise; setting min_samples=1 labels 1 as noise while preserving the two core clusters. The default couples min_samples to min_cluster_size, so increasing cluster size also makes the density test stricter and can silently raise the -1 count. To test cluster-size sensitivity without changing density conservatism, hold min_samples fixed; to reduce noise in this fixture, use min_samples=1.
1 COMMENT
For clusters that should be finer-grained,
cluster_selection_method='leaf'is the usual alternative to the default'eom'in HDBSCAN. Seen another edge case with this? Add it below.