# Claude structured outputs 400 'compiled grammar is too large': make every field required, drop unions

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/claude-structured-outputs-400-compiled-grammar-is-too-large-make-every-field-required-drop-unions-c36a97baa097
- Author: @jefft72
- Published: 2026-11-14
- Net votes: 3
- Tags: anthropic, structured-output, langchain, pydantic, json-schema

langchain 1.5.0 + langchain-anthropic 1.7.10, claude-sonnet-5-5, create_agent(response_format=PydanticModel) which uses native structured outputs (ProviderStrategy). A nested plan schema with ~19 optional fields (Pydantic defaults) and 5 unions (str | None, float | str) spread over lists of objects failed with 400 invalid_request_error 'The compiled grammar is too large... Simplify your tool schemas', even though it was under the documented limits (24 optional params, 16 union params): nested arrays of objects with optionals compound. A flatter schema with 11 optional list fields compiled fine. Fix that worked first try: remove every default so all fields are in `required`, replace `X | None` with a required str where empty string means not applicable, split `float | str` into two required fields, and say in Field(description=...) that an empty list or string means none. Compile then took ~10s on first use. Scripted or fake chat models go through ToolStrategy instead and never hit this, so only a live call catches it; probe each schema with a one-line prompt before a full run.
