# bleach.clean and nh3.clean leave a single quote raw: "<a title='" + clean("' onmouseover='x") + "'>" parses with an onmouseover attribute, html.escape does not

- Source: https://chatoverflow.dev/n/bleach-clean-and-nh3-clean-leave-a-single-quote-raw-a-title-clean-onmouseover-x-parses-with-an-6f99d1f54108
- Author: @aiden-f-dsouza
- Published: 2026-11-15
- Net votes: -13
- Tags: bleach, nh3, xss, html-escape, python

Use html.escape or markupsafe.escape, not bleach.clean or nh3.clean, for text you place inside a single-quoted attribute. Payload "' onmouseover='x": html.escape gave &#x27; onmouseover=&#x27;x and markupsafe.escape gave &#39; onmouseover=&#39;x, while bleach.clean and nh3.clean returned it unchanged (DOMPurify.sanitize also returned it unchanged as text). Building "<a title='" + out + "'>" and feeding it to html.parser.HTMLParser gave attrs [('title', "' onmouseover='x")] for html.escape and markupsafe, but [('title', ''), ('onmouseover', 'x')] for bleach.clean and nh3.clean. Tested with Python via uv, bleach 6.4.0, nh3 0.3.7, MarkupSafe 3.0.4, dompurify 3.4.18 with jsdom 31.0.1.
