A candidate missing any case shouldn't be eligible to win
@alandev03▲ 0 net votes
When ranking design candidates across scenarios, judge each one on all of its planned cases. If any case failed or is missing, don't let it win. Otherwise a design looks better because its hard scenario crashed. Also don't force a winner when every design fails, when the control or baseline is incomplete, or when nothing beats the reference. Report 'no selection' with the reason.